1821 marked Central American countries’ independence from Spain

Editor’s note: “Behind the News” is the product of Sun staff assisted by the Sun’s AI lab, which includes a variety of tools such as Anthropic’s Claude, Perplexity AI, Google Gemini and ChatGPT.

Today marks the anniversary when the provinces of Central America — Guatemala, El Salvador, Honduras, Nicaragua and Costa Rica — jointly declared independence from Spain in 1821 [2][7][8].

This decision was articulated in the Act of Independence of Central America, reflecting shared colonial governance under the Captaincy General of Guatemala and Spain’s weakening grip on its colonies [2][3].

While the act demonstrated remarkable regional unity, this cohesion proved short-lived, revealing deep divisions that would eventually fracture the political project [2][5].

Administrative unity and shared institutions

Central America’s joint declaration stemmed from its colonial administrative design. Since the 16th century, the region has been governed as the Captaincy General of Guatemala, a subdivision of the Viceroyalty of New Spain. Guatemala City served as the political hub, hosting the Audiencia of Guatemala and the University of San Carlos, the region’s only institution of higher learning [11][12].

Although regional identities remained distinct, administrative cohesion created shared legal institutions, taxation systems and political communication channels[8]. When independence sentiments spread, provinces were inclined to act collectively rather than in isolation.

Revolutionary influences and constitutional openings

Central America’s independence trajectory was shaped by broader revolutionary currents. The American and French Revolutions demonstrated that colonial populations could overthrow metropolitan rulers, providing ideological inspiration emphasizing natural rights and representative government [4][13].

Most consequential was the Peninsular War (1808-1814), when Napoleon invaded Spain and ousted King Ferdinand VII [2][4]. This crisis undermined Spain’s colonial authority, leaving officials uncertain about which government to obey [2][4]. Such ambiguity emboldened many to contemplate independence [4].

Spain’s liberal Constitution of Cádiz in 1812 provided another decisive influence, granting colonial representation and limiting monarchical authority [3][4]. Town councils gained prominence, and creole elites became increasingly active in governance [3][4]. When Ferdinand VII restored absolutism in 1814, disappointment grew among Central American leaders [4]. The oscillation between authoritarian restoration and liberal openings disillusioned elites who began doubting Madrid’s capacity for stable governance [4].

The declaration and early divisions

By 1821, conditions aligned for action. Growing unease over Spain’s weakness, combined with pressure from newly independent Mexico, convinced elites the moment was ripe [7]. On Sept. 15, Guatemala City’s Provincial Council adopted the Act of Independence, declaring the five provinces free from Spanish sovereignty[7][8]. Nine of 13 signers were University of San Carlos graduates, demonstrating the institution’s central role in producing independence leadership [11].

The Mexican question and federal experiment

Almost immediately, provinces faced a crucial decision: remain independent as a federation or join the Mexican Empire under Agustín de Iturbide [2]. Conservatives favored Mexico for monarchical order, while liberals opposed annexation, fearing authoritarian domination [2]. El Salvador briefly resisted union with Mexico [2]. Most provinces ultimately submitted to Mexican annexation by 1822, though resentments festered [2][9].

When the Mexican Empire collapsed in 1823, Central America declared independence again, establishing the Federal Republic of Central America (1823-1838) [2]. Despite adopting a federal constitution in 1824, the republic quickly encountered structural difficulties [10]. Regional rivalries intensified, the federation lacked financial resources and stable military, and local caudillos resisted centralized authority [10]. Civil wars erupted throughout the 1820s and 1830s [10]. Francisco Morazán emerged as a liberal figure attempting to preserve unity but was executed in 1842, marking the federation’s end [5].

By 1838, provinces began seceding, and by the early 1840s, the federal project dissolved into independent nation-states [5].

Historical legacy

The Act of Independence stands as a pivotal moment revealing both unity’s promise and fragmentation’s persistence[7][8]. The joint declaration reflected centuries of shared governance under the Captaincy General, which created necessary structures for collective action [1][9]. Global revolutionary movements, Spain’s crises, and liberal constitutional ideals provided the catalyst for independence [3][4][13].

Yet the aftermath demonstrated the difficulties of maintaining cohesion [5][10]. Divergent interests, geographic realities and competing governance visions made sustained unity nearly impossible [2][5][10]. For modern Central America, Sept. 15 remains a shared commemoration day [7][8][14], recognizing their collective severance from Spain while remembering the challenges their ancestors faced in seeking unity amid diversity [5][10].

Sources

[2] https://www.britannica.com/place/Central-America/Independence-1808-23

[3] https://andscape.com/features/on-this-day-in-latinx-history-the-act-of-independence-of-central-america/

[4] https://www.vamosforschools.co.uk/hispanic-world/history/central-america-independence/

[5] https://www.britannica.com/place/United-Provinces-of-Central-America

[7] https://costarica.org/events/holidays/independence/

[8] https://cowlatinamerica.voices.wooster.edu/archive-item/act-of-independence-from-central-america/

[10] https://www.ebsco.com/research-starters/history/central-american-federation-civil-wars

[11] https://www.encyclopedia.com/humanities/encyclopedias-almanacs-transcripts-and-maps/san-carlos-de-guatemala-university

[13] https://oceanposse.com/central-america-celebrates-independence-from-spanish-rule/

[14] https://www.auswaertiges-amt.de/en/aussenpolitik/regionaleschwerpunkte/lateinamerika/-/2480956