Lindsay Clancy’s lawyer now questions whether she killed her 3 children

PLYMOUTH, Mass. — Lindsay Clancy ‘s lawyer argued Tuesday that determination wasn’t capable grounds to beryllium she killed her 3 children, a striking crook aft a lengthy proceedings that focused much connected her intelligence authorities than connected whether she took their lives.

“This full lawsuit is based connected speculation,” lawyer Kevin Reddington said during the archetypal proceeding since Clancy’s archetypal proceedings ended Sept. 4 with a deadlocked jury. They were divided 11 to 1 successful her favor.

During the trial, Reddington didn’t quality that Clancy killed the children astatine the family’s location successful 2023. Instead, the defence sought to transportation the assemblage that the 36-year-old erstwhile labour and transportation caregiver was not criminally liable due to the fact that of intelligence disease, a uncommon information called postpartum psychosis.

———

EDITOR’S NOTE: This communicative includes treatment of suicide. If you oregon idiosyncratic you cognize needs help, the nationalist termination and situation lifeline successful the U.S. is disposable by calling oregon texting 988.

———

Clancy’s lawyer present says there’s not capable grounds to beryllium she did it

But connected Tuesday, Reddington sought to transportation Judge William Sullivan — the aforesaid justice who presided implicit the archetypal proceedings — to acquit Clancy.

There is, Reddington contended, not capable grounds “that this pistillate killed those children.” He pointed to matters ranging from her information erstwhile she was found, severely injured and bleeding successful the gait extracurricular her home, to her deficiency of representation of what happened erstwhile she woke up successful a hospital. At the archetypal trial, her present ex-husband and archetypal responders testified that they arrived astatine the location and discovered she had tried to termination herself close aft sidesplitting the children.

“Where is the admission? Where does she accidental that she did this?” Reddington asked, going connected to recap his arguments that she besides was psychotic and delusional astatine the clip of the children’s deaths.

Prosecutor Shanan Buckingham called his statement “laughable,” pointing to assorted grounds raised during the trial. In tribunal papers filed Monday, prosecutors recapped their arguments that determination was capable grounds to convict Clancy.

The prosecution maintains that Clancy, a 36-year-old erstwhile labour and transportation nurse, strangled the children with workout bands past utilized aggregate methods to effort to extremity her life, and that she knew what she was doing was wrong. She remains paralyzed from the waist down.

It’s inactive chartless whether Clancy volition look a 2nd trial

The justice didn’t instantly decide, and nary proceedings day was set.

Prosecutors person yet to determine whether to retry Clancy, Plymouth County District Attorney Timothy Cruz said aft the hearing. They could take to retry her connected first-degree execution charges oregon question to effort her lone connected lesser charges, including second-degree execution oregon manslaughter, oregon driblet the lawsuit entirely.

“We are going to bash what we tin for the children,” Cruz told reporters extracurricular the court. “That is what this lawsuit is about.”

Legal wrangling implicit the holdout juror is besides unresolved

Clancy’s attorneys person besides asked the justice to disregard the transgression case. Among different things, they person argued that the justice should person ousted the 1 juror who favored a execution condemnation aft the assemblage foreperson complained helium was refusing to perceive to the instrumentality connected tenable doubt.

The juror, Michael Desronvil, has said done his lawyer that helium had nary doubts astir his stance. Desronvil told Fox News’ “Hannity” successful a little video connection connected Monday that “the full absorption has been connected me, but we privation to reel everything backmost and enactment the absorption connected the 3 angels,” meaning the children.

The defence has besides asked the justice to analyse the juror’s truthfulness connected a questionnaire that prospective jurors filled retired earlier the proceedings began, his truthfulness erstwhile jurors were questioned by the justice a time earlier the proceedings ended and besides whether helium broke tribunal rules by utilizing a cellphone during deliberations.

Clancy’s high-profile lawsuit is inactive capturing people’s attention

The livestreamed proceedings generated aggravated nationalist involvement and drew attraction to maternal intelligence wellness aft childbirth. About a twelve Clancy supporters, astir dressed successful pink, stood extracurricular tribunal Tuesday waiting for her to arrive.

Clancy remains charged with execution and is expected to enactment astatine a psychiatric infirmary until her lawsuit is resolved.

Clancy could person been sentenced to beingness successful situation if convicted of murder. If acquitted, the justice could person ordered her confined to a intelligence wellness facility.