2 hours ago Just now
Noor Nanji,Culture correspondent, Katy Watson,Sydney correspondentand Georgia MacPherson,BBC Panorama
BBC
Married astatine First Sight Australia stars accidental the amusement near them feeling unsafe and unprotected due to the fact that their on-screen partners had transgression pasts which they were not told about, a BBC probe tin reveal.
It comes aft the British mentation of the show, known to galore arsenic MAFS UK, was plunged into situation aft BBC Panorama reported rape allegations from 2 women contestants - allegations the men progressive person denied.
One pistillate from past year's Australian bid says she was not told the antheral she had been matched with had a erstwhile cause condemnation and lone recovered retired aft the amusement ended. "There should beryllium informed consent," she told us.
We tin besides uncover that different groom from the aforesaid bid had a past condemnation for affray, which we recognize his on-screen bride was not made alert of.
Nine erstwhile formed members from MAFS Australia person spoken to the BBC and are present calling connected the amusement to amended its inheritance checks and to halt allowing individuals with erstwhile convictions oregon allegations connected the show.
MAFS Australia is not made by the aforesaid accumulation institution arsenic MAFS UK. Endemol Shine Australia is down the show, which airs successful Australia connected Channel 9.
In a associated statement, Channel 9 and Endemol Shine Australia said they had "strong protocols successful spot to guarantee subordinate information and wellbeing".
As good arsenic being a immense deed successful Australia, the amusement is fashionable successful the UK and is shown connected Channel 4. The broadcaster has pulled each the UK episodes of MAFS from its streaming work All 4, but MAFS Australia remains disposable to watch.
Both programmes amusement azygous radical agreeing to "marry" full strangers aft gathering for the archetypal clip astatine their mock weddings.
The marriages are not legally binding, but viewers spot the couples spell connected "honeymoons", earlier moving successful unneurotic and navigating their relationships - each portion being filmed, astir each day.
Several antheral contestants person been allowed connected MAFS Australia contempt having been convicted of, oregon having faced allegations of, violence, battle oregon cause use.
The BBC is reporting immoderate of these details for the archetypal time, portion others person antecedently been reported successful Australian media. We recovered galore of the details successful tribunal records connected a publically accessible database.
Some pistillate formed members we spoke to told america they had not been not informed astir their partners' transgression pasts erstwhile they were matched.
When we asked Channel 9 whether they had been - the broadcaster did not reply that circumstantial question, but told america its protocols did not see sharing idiosyncratic oregon inheritance accusation betwixt participants.
'Brides are not harmless connected MAFS Australia'
Sierah Swepstone, from past year's series, says she feels fto down by the show's producers.
She was formed with Billy Belcher, who was arrested and sentenced successful 2014 for aggregate drug-related offences successful Perth.
She says she was not told astir his erstwhile condemnation and lone recovered retired aft the amusement ended.
Sierah Swepstone
"There should beryllium informed consent" regarding who you are paired with connected the show, says Sierah Swepstone
"You shouldn't beryllium near unsocial with a alien with a transgression record," Swepstone told us.
"At the precise least, determination should beryllium informed consent. They should fto america know. Why is the amusement accepting that hazard connected our behalf? We should person the choice."
Swepstone present feels powerfully that she was not protected connected the amusement and says it failed successful its work of attraction towards her.
"Brides are not harmless connected MAFS Australia," she says.
Belcher did not respond to a petition for comment.
Channel 9 and Endemol Shine Australia pointed america to a erstwhile connection which said: "Billy was wholly honorable with accumulation astir the beingness lessons helium learnt erstwhile helium was 18, aft receiving a suspended condemnation with bully behaviour for cause related offences."
They besides said determination were nary accusations oregon convictions successful narration to unit oregon maltreatment of immoderate sort.
Another erstwhile contestant besides told america her on-screen spouse had told her during filming that helium had behaved aggressively successful the past, and that producers knew.
"I was terrified the full time," says the woman, who has asked to stay anonymous for fearfulness of repercussions. We are calling her Anna.
"I thought I'd beryllium safe, that's wherefore I signed up to the show."
She was near traumatised by her experience, she says.
He had a temper, Anna says, and connected 1 juncture threw a mic-pack astatine a wall, smashing it into pieces portion swearing. Another time, she says helium threw an entity astatine producers during filming.
BBC News has besides seen a representation of a bruise she sent during filming to a fig that we person verified belongs to her on-screen partner, who responded: "Shit! I'm truthful sorry."
Channel 9 and Endemol Shine Australia told america the antheral contestant was progressive successful an isolated lawsuit respective years anterior to MAFS Australia. They said helium did not person a transgression grounds and they had nary grounds of the allegations of him throwing the mic-pack and oregon the different object.
Anna's on-screen hubby says helium "categorically denies each allegation" raised by her, oregon regarding his past. "These claims are wholly false, malicious, and a implicit distortion of reality," helium adds.
Anna says her occupation is chiefly with the amusement for allowing her to beryllium successful that situation.
"Channel 9 are making wealth disconnected radical who are vulnerable," she says. "They did the checks and they knew astir his background, and they formed him anyhow arsenic it makes 'good TV.'"
Cast members with past convictions besides see Adrian Araouzou, a groom connected the 2025 series.
Prior to his world TV stint, the BBC has learned helium received a 2017 condemnation for affray.
Previously, it was reported helium had besides been acquitted of home violence, and that details of his proceedings had emerged during filming.
When asked for a effect by BBC News, Araouzou said it was "none of your business" and told america the accusation we had enactment to him was "false".
We asked Channel 9 and Endemol Shine Australia whether they had told Araouzou's on-screen spouse astir the condemnation for affray. We recognize she had not been told.
They said: "All participants connected MAFS, including Adrian, acquisition extended inheritance checks including constabulary checks."
They besides said: "The affray condemnation was 9 years ago, and the punishment was a $400 [£210] fine, placing this astatine the lowest extremity of the spectrum for this offence arsenic determined by the court".
Other antheral formed members with transgression histories see Timothy Smith, who took portion successful the 2024 series.
After filming connected the show, Smith confirmed helium had antecedently spent a twelvemonth successful a US situation aft pleading blameworthy to cause trafficking. On his website, helium describes himself arsenic "cartel aviator to firm leader".
Smith told the BBC helium stood by what helium had said of his past. Channel 9 and Endemol Shine Australia said his conviction, which was successful the US, was not revealed by him until aft the bid was broadcast.
Separately, Chris Nield, from the latest series, was antecedently recovered blameworthy of communal assault. Nield did not respond to our petition for comment.
Channel 9 and Endemol Shine Australia said Nield's condemnation arose from a one-off altercation and determination had been nary repetition behaviour successful the 11 years since.
The amusement 'dropped the ball'
We person spoken to respective further Australian formed members who person concerns astir the casting process connected the show.
One groom, who asked to stay anonymous, told the BBC determination had lone been 2 weeks betwixt him applying for the amusement and filming starting.
The checks had been "rushed", helium said. When helium could not find definite documentation to beryllium helium did not person a transgression record, helium says the show's producers told him they would "just instrumentality his connection for it" arsenic they were successful a hurry to get started.
"I didn't person a transgression record, but it raises the question implicit what happens if they enactment idiosyncratic connected the amusement who does person a history," helium said.
Katie Johnstone
If you are paired with idiosyncratic with a "sketchy background", you should beryllium made aware, says Katie Johnstone
Other formed members besides said they felt the amusement had "dropped the ball" erstwhile it came to inheritance checks. They see Katie Johnstone, from the 2025 series, and Tahnee Cook from the 2023 series.
Neither were partnered with men with past convictions, but they accidental they are alert of others who were.
"If you're with idiosyncratic who has a sketchy background, past you should beryllium made alert of that," said Johnstone.
"Especially considering you're expected to beryllium unsocial and stock a country with this person," she added. "You request to cognize and it's not just that women are being placed successful these positions."
"These checks can't conscionable beryllium a tick box," added Cook. "I don't deliberation you should beryllium allowed connected with immoderate erstwhile offence. I deliberation it's unsafe."
Our Watch, an Australian non-profit organisation aiming to forestall unit against women, told the BBC that allegations oregon convictions indispensable beryllium treated arsenic "a superior safeguarding issue" by TV productions, "and not withheld from the radical astir astatine risk".
Channel 9 and Endemol Shine Australia said they instrumentality their obligations successful respect of the health, wellbeing and information of participants "extremely seriously".
"There is simply a structured, multi-stage checking process that each subordinate indispensable implicit and clear," they said - including constabulary and criminal-history checks successful each declared state of residence, autarkic objective intelligence assessment, aesculapian screening, disclosure supported by a statutory declaration, and ineligible and integer owed diligence.
Channel 4 said it is not progressive successful the accumulation of MAFS Australia and has "no editorial power oregon input" into its making.
"However, Channel 4 ensures immoderate mentation it transmits of acquired programmes adheres to the Ofcom Broadcasting Code."
- If you person much accusation astir this story, you tin scope Noor by email astatine noor.nanji@bbc.co.uk
English (US)·