'Officials can't use common sense' - was Rogers handball correct?

2 hours ago 2 min read 6
⚡ Sincity Press Brief

The decision to give Leeds a crucial penalty in their win at Chelsea reopens the Premier League handball debate around intent.

'Officials can't use common sense' - was Rogers handball correct?

The feeling among Premier League clubs is that handball is successful a bully spot now, wherever the limb indispensable either beryllium afloat extended distant from the body, raised, oregon beryllium a deliberate enactment to beryllium punishable.

And it is the past of these that applied to the punishment fixed against Rogers, which to immoderate mightiness look a spot harsh, considering the Premier League's much relaxed mentation of handball.

There are, however, a fewer cardinal reasons wherefore referee Michael Oliver pointed to the spot, wherefore the video adjunct referee (VAR) did not intervene, and wherefore it volition beryllium judged arsenic a close decision.

Two of the factors which a referee looks for erstwhile judging a imaginable handball use here.

First, however acold the shot travelled.

As Jayden Bogle's changeable was from distance, a defender is considered to person much clip to set their assemblage and respond - and frankincense debar a imaginable handball.

Most important successful this lawsuit is the question of the arm.

When Bogle shoots, Rogers' limb is not raised - but it comes up to the formation of the ball.

Crucially, had Rogers kept his limb successful its archetypal presumption - little and level with his midriff - determination would not person been a handball offence.

What does this mean? Put simply, if the shot would person deed the assemblage if it had not travel disconnected the arm, it is considered to person nary impact.

But this lawsuit was different. Rogers raised his limb and that is what led to the shot being deflected away. This is considered a deliberate act, and this trumps each different considerations.

Read the full story at BBC News →
Up nextCan win over All Blacks finally break England's boom-bust cycle?